Does Your College Essay Need a Title? And Why Pineapples Don’t Belong on Pizza

When it comes to writing a college essay, one of the most debated questions is whether or not it needs a title. Some argue that a title is essential, while others believe it’s unnecessary. But let’s take a step back and consider this: does your college essay need a title, and why does this question feel as polarizing as the pineapple-on-pizza debate?
The Case for Titles
-
First Impressions Matter
A title is the first thing your reader sees. It sets the tone and provides a glimpse into the content of your essay. A well-crafted title can intrigue the admissions officer and make them eager to read more. -
Clarity and Focus
A title can help you stay focused on your main idea. It serves as a guiding star, ensuring that your essay doesn’t stray too far from its central theme. -
Creativity Showcase
A clever or unique title can demonstrate your creativity and writing skills. It’s an opportunity to stand out from the thousands of other essays admissions officers read. -
Professionalism
Including a title can make your essay feel more polished and complete. It shows that you’ve put thought into every aspect of your application.
The Case Against Titles
-
Time-Consuming
Crafting the perfect title can be time-consuming. For some students, this time might be better spent refining the content of the essay itself. -
Risk of Overthinking
A poorly chosen title can detract from your essay. If it’s too vague, cliché, or unrelated, it might confuse or even annoy the reader. -
Not Always Required
Many colleges don’t explicitly require a title. If the prompt doesn’t mention it, you might be better off skipping it altogether. -
Focus on Content
Admissions officers are primarily interested in the substance of your essay. A title, while nice, won’t make or break your application if the content is strong.
The Pineapple-on-Pizza Parallel
Now, let’s address the elephant in the room: why does this debate feel so much like the pineapple-on-pizza controversy? Both topics spark passionate arguments, with people firmly entrenched in their positions. Just as some believe pineapple has no place on pizza, others argue that a college essay doesn’t need a title.
The truth is, both debates are subjective. Whether you love or hate pineapple on pizza, or whether you include a title in your essay, ultimately comes down to personal preference. What matters most is that your choice aligns with your goals and enhances the overall experience—whether that’s enjoying a slice of pizza or crafting a compelling college essay.
Practical Tips for Deciding
-
Read the Prompt Carefully
If the prompt explicitly asks for a title, include one. If it doesn’t, consider whether a title adds value to your essay. -
Keep It Simple
If you decide to include a title, make it concise and relevant. Avoid overly clever or cryptic titles that might confuse the reader. -
Test It Out
Share your essay with a trusted teacher, mentor, or friend. Ask them if the title enhances their understanding or enjoyment of your essay. -
Don’t Stress Too Much
Remember, the title is just one small part of your essay. Focus on telling your story authentically and passionately.
Final Thoughts
In the end, whether or not your college essay needs a title is up to you. Just like the pineapple-on-pizza debate, there’s no right or wrong answer—only what works best for you. So, take a deep breath, trust your instincts, and write the essay that feels true to who you are.
Related Q&A
Q: Can a title make or break my college essay?
A: While a great title can enhance your essay, it’s unlikely to make or break your application. Focus on the content and storytelling first.
Q: Should I use a humorous title for my essay?
A: Humor can be effective, but it’s risky. Make sure it aligns with the tone of your essay and doesn’t come across as unprofessional.
Q: What if I can’t think of a title?
A: If you’re stuck, it’s okay to skip the title. A strong essay without a title is better than a weak essay with a forced one.
Q: How long should my title be?
A: Keep it short and sweet—ideally, no more than a few words or a brief phrase.
Q: Can I change my title after writing the essay?
A: Absolutely! Your title can evolve as your essay takes shape. Don’t be afraid to revise it until it feels just right.